Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Further thoughts on 'The Rouse"

Amazon

I think there's a genuine structural problem with the novel. In its middle sections, it becomes an interminable shaggy-dog story in which the hero Stallo's life essentially unravels, decade by decade. He grows into an old man. There are endless adventures, but few highs and lows, little emotional impact, little plot development and scant engagement with the reader.

It's almost like reading an endless series of newspaper articles about weird, semi-inexplicable events happening in faraway places. It's well written, but doesn't particularly engage the reader's interest or emotions.

If the intention is to convey that the phenomena are complicated, hard to control and ontologically opaque, and that the underlying architecture of reality is difficult to ascertain, I think the reader grasps that fairly early in the book. Nothing that happens subsequently particularly changes or deepens that understanding. And in the end, we have no real conclusion.

So I think the novel is clever, but rather lifeless. Miéville doesn't seem to have been thinking very much about the reader.

It's almost like a reimagining of China Miéville's own experiences of life on the revolutionary left, its failures, and his increasingly jaundiced view of whether his worldview was ever correct. Perhaps, he has come to believe, there are mysteries that mean everything he has lived for is becoming stale, ungrounded, flaky and ultimately purposeless.

In that sense, the novel represents an interior exploration of China Miéville's own crisis of the spirit, a crisis of worldview. And that's not necessarily terribly interesting to people who didn't share Miéville's intellectual formation in the first place or who, as in my case, managed to find rather more satisfactory ways out of the impasse than Miéville appears to have found.

[GPT-6 Astra comment on the above].


No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated. Keep it polite and no gratuitous links to your business website - we're not a billboard here.