'When I was fourteen years old' - by Adam Carlton

---

I am a materialist. As Don Cupitt explained on TV the other night, everything we experience—from the tiniest speck of dust to the vast and starry sky—is accounted for by science. Lawrence Krauss says the whole show probably started as a quantum fluctuation in unstable nothingness. Imagine that. Nothing kinda flickers and suddenly, boom—the universe.  

And all the politics, the economics, the moral dilemmas, the habits and deliberations of thoughtful people like me—it’s all explained by Darwinism. More science. It all fits together, neat as clockwork.  

But when I say I am a materialist, I can’t help but quibble over the ‘I’. Science tells me that rocks, flowers, and I are just different arrangements of the same raw stuff. But unlike me, rocks and flowers don’t seem to sit around wondering about it. They don’t argue with themselves at three in the morning about free will or feel slightly uncomfortable about being nothing more than glorified chemical reactions.

So I suppose I’m a materialist about everything except the ‘I’ part.  

Not that I’m saying there isn’t a materialist explanation—it’s just that nobody’s been able to show me how that would work. Nobody seems to know. And only last year, I still thought scientists knew everything.  

I’m not drawing any conclusions. I’m not sneaking a ‘God of the Gaps’ in through the back door. I’m just saying: it feels like a mystery. A real, solid, uncracked mystery. Just like how nobody truly understands what reality is, underneath all that quantum weirdness.  

Maybe our brains, locked inside our skulls, just invented everything—from time to space to physics—out of pure, floating ideas!  

Wow. 

Was Hegel a Christian? - A question to Gemini

Was Hegel a Christian? What was the relationship between the absolute spirit and the christian God?

---

1. Was Hegel a Christian?

The answer is nuanced:

• Formally/Culturally: Yes. Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831) was born, baptized, and confirmed in the Lutheran faith, the dominant Protestant tradition in his region of Germany. He maintained his formal affiliation with the Lutheran Church throughout his life, worked in theological seminaries early in his career, and often framed his philosophical work in relation to Christian concepts. He certainly operated within a Christian cultural context.
• Philosophically/Theologically: This is highly debatable and depends heavily on the definition of "Christian."
  • Hegel saw his philosophy as the culmination of Western thought, which he believed reached its highest religious expression in Christianity. He aimed to translate the representational truths of Christian dogma (which he called Vorstellung – pictorial or symbolic thought) into the conceptual, rational form of philosophy (Begriff – the concept).
  • However, his interpretation of Christian doctrines was radically different from traditional orthodoxy. Many theologians and philosophers, both during his time and since, have argued that Hegel's system fundamentally alters or subverts core Christian beliefs, even while using Christian language. Accusations ranged from pantheism (God is the world) or panentheism (the world is in God) to essentially replacing the traditional God with his own concept of Absolute Spirit.
  • He believed philosophy offered a higher, more complete understanding of the truths that religion presented symbolically. For some, this elevates philosophy above faith in a way incompatible with traditional Christianity.

In summary: Hegel was culturally and formally a Lutheran Christian. However, whether his philosophy constitutes a genuinely Christian worldview, rather than a philosophical reinterpretation or replacement of it, is a central point of contention in Hegel scholarship. He certainly engaged deeply with Christianity, but not typically in a way that orthodox believers of his time (or ours) would recognize as straightforward affirmation.

2. The Relationship Between Absolute Spirit (Geist) and the Christian God

This is the core of Hegel's philosophical reinterpretation of religion:

• Identification via Reinterpretation: Hegel often explicitly identifies the Absolute Spirit (Geist) with God. He saw the Christian concept of God, particularly the doctrine of the Trinity and the Incarnation, as the highest religious representation of the nature of the Absolute.³
• God as Process: Unlike the traditional view of God as a largely static, transcendent being existing separately from the world, Hegel's Absolute Spirit is dynamic.⁴ It is a process of self-realization and self-consciousness that unfolds through the entirety of reality – including logic, nature, and human history. God becomes fully self-aware through this cosmic and historical process.
• Immanence over Transcendence: While traditional Christianity holds both God's immanence (presence within the world) and transcendence (existence beyond the world), Hegel heavily emphasizes immanence. The Absolute Spirit is the rational structure and driving force within the world's development. The world is the manifestation of God/Spirit.
• Philosophical Trinity: Hegel interpreted the Christian Trinity (Father, Son, Holy Spirit) not primarily as three distinct persons in one Godhead (in the traditional sense), but as representing the logical structure of the Absolute itself:
  • Father: The abstract, universal potentiality of Spirit (akin to pure logic or Being).
  • Son: The externalization or particularization of Spirit in the finite world (Nature and finite minds, culminating in the figure of Christ as the moment God becomes conscious of unity with humanity).
  • Holy Spirit: The return of Spirit to itself, achieving self-consciousness through the community (especially the state, art, religion, and philosophy).
• Culmination in Philosophy: For Hegel, religion (specifically Christianity) grasps the truth about the Absolute in symbolic form (Vorstellung). Philosophy, however, grasps this same truth in its ultimate, rational, conceptual form (Begriff). Therefore, philosophy provides the final, most adequate understanding of what religion intuits.

In essence: Hegel viewed the Christian God as the most developed symbolic representation of the ultimate reality, which he conceptually defined as the Absolute Spirit. He didn't simply equate the two in a traditional sense; rather, he philosophically reinterpreted the Christian God as the Absolute Spirit unfolding immanently through the rational process of world history. This identification profoundly reshaped the concept of God, moving away from traditional transcendence towards an immanent, dynamic, and ultimately self-comprehending rational process that is reality.